Share:

New York — what we buy, and what would survive a 5% bar

May to August 2026 only. Booking rates and lead costs are measured on Jul 26, Aug 26 only — three settled months, so a lead has had time to book and a real invoice has priced it. Costs are the suppliers’ invoiced costs, unadjusted.
Leads a month now
8,191
Jul 26, Aug 26
Would survive the bar
2,741
48% of what New York buys now
Segments that qualify
4 of 17
Adult Insta, Kids Meta/Insta, Alan 3CX, Alan Facebook
Booking rate on those
6.95%
vs 5% bar
Cost per lead
$20.67
on the qualifying segments
Cost per booking
$297
at that rate and price
Needed to fill 553 slots
5,122
356 bookings a month at 6.95%
Short by
2,381
a month, against what qualifies today
New York buys 8,191 leads a month. At a 5% bar, 2,741 of them would survive — 48%. Those leads book at 6.95% and cost $20.67, so a booking costs $297. Filling New York’s 553 slots needs 356 bookings, which is 5,122 qualifying leads a month — 2,381 more a month than qualify today. That is what we are not currently buying, which is not the same as what the supplier cannot deliver.

Leads bought every month

Purple bar is everything bought; green is the part that would survive the 5% bar. Recycled codes are excluded throughout — they cost no new ad money.

MonthLeads boughtWould surviveShareKidsAdultsVolume
May 267,7003,87050.3%2,8251,045
Jun 265,9211,92632.5%1,381545
Jul 268,2221,73421.1%970764
Aug 268,1593,74845.9%2,7391,009
NOW (Jul 26, Aug 26)8,1912,74147.9%
Every price here was found. Where one was not found, no price is shown. Blue Rooms leads are priced from Blue Rooms’ own per-family cost per lead off the USA Models admin dashboard (KIDSX $22.26, 1FX $17.28, SNAP $26.43, GX $18.40, PX $27.85, DX $26.37 — 2026-08). Alan and Lead Pronto are priced only where the supplier actually invoiced that code that month. Everything else is unpriced and blank: no city average, no code average, and nothing derived by dividing a supplier’s spend by our own lead count. 68% of New York’s qualifying leads carry a found price, and the costs above are the average of those only.
Two Blue Rooms figures disagree and it is not resolved. Their /api/reporting/spend feed reports $401,849 for August while their admin dashboard reports $544,290 — $142,441 apart, 35%. The per-family prices used here come from the dashboard, the higher of the two. That gap alone is larger than the ~$101k/month that previously could not be accounted for between the invoices and real ad spend, so the two are probably the same hole. It needs putting to Blue Rooms rather than picked between.

Every segment New York buys

Rates measured on Jul 26, Aug 26. A segment under 100 leads in that window is marked too thin to judge — it is not a segment that failed, it is one we cannot rate yet, and it is excluded from the surviving volume above.

SegmentLeads / monthMay 26Jun 26Jul 26Aug 26JUL+AUGCost / leadCost / bookingBanked / leadVerdict
Adult Insta (1FX)6636.07%8.92%7.20%8.31%7.77%$17.28$222$51.91BUY
Kids Meta/Insta (KIDSX) KIDS1,8557.01%6.15%7.84%6.46%6.82%$22.26$326$60.20BUY
Alan 3CX1646.03%1.64%—5.28%5.79%$13.92$240$38.69BUY
Alan Facebook601.19%4.85%5.00%—5.00%——$33.39BUY
Lead Pronto4603.73%4.62%3.82%4.93%4.46%$10.70$240$29.76drop
Adult Google PMax (GX)509—1.63%4.83%1.34%4.32%$18.40$426$28.86drop
Adult Snapchat5232.00%5.01%3.96%4.44%4.21%$26.43$628$28.09drop
Kids Google PMax (KX) KIDS995—4.64%2.23%2.00%2.21%$22.26$1,006$19.52drop
Alan Instagram634.07%——2.11%1.60%$18.92$1,183$10.69drop
Alan / other4251.71%—1.45%0.64%1.30%$25.72$1,985$8.65drop
Alan 4AB4————too thin———too thin to judge
Kids (bare KIDS) KIDS0————too thin———too thin to judge
2 segments in New York carry too few leads to rate (4 a month between them). They are held out of the surviving volume rather than counted as failures. If any of them matter, they need a longer window than three months before the bar is applied to them.

Recycled — the cheapest booking in New York, by a distance

Priced at $1.00 a lead. These are people who already came in once and are worked again, so they sit here and are never blended into the fresh buy above — counting them in both places would credit one person twice.

StageLeads / monthMay 26Jun 26JUL+AUGBookings / monthCost / leadCost / booking
Recycled 5AB1434.15%4.91%6.99%10$1.00$14
Recycled CMN35010.16%12.31%5.87%21$1.00$17
Recycled 6AB8654.90%4.08%4.97%43$1.00$20
Recycled (R-suffix)1034.28%3.03%2.93%3$1.00$34
Recycled N1N1,0132.04%2.82%1.93%20$1.00$52
ALL RECYCLED2,4733.88%96$1.00$26
New York already works 2,473 recycled leads a month for 96 bookings at $26 each — against $297 for a fresh booking here. On money alone there is no contest, which is why “how many should we bring in” is not a budget question.
What the $1.00 does not include — and it is the whole answer. It is the list cost. The real cost of a recycled lead is booker time, which sits in payroll and is in no feed here. At 3.88% a booker works 26 recycled leads per booking against 14 fresh ones — about 1.8× the effort. So the ceiling on recycled is how many the room can work and how deep the list goes, not what they cost. Neither is measured here, and a real answer to “how many” needs both: the size of the un-worked pile, and a per-booker view of leads actually worked. Show rate and revenue per arrival are also not measured for recycled, so these stay cost-per-booking figures and are deliberately not turned into revenue.

Network view: https://reports.iconicbyai.com/Studio1_Lead_Mix_Model.html · all cities: https://reports.iconicbyai.com/Studio1_City_Buy.html