Share:

Is the Outreach Work Helping?

Generated 17 November 2026 — outreach pipeline customers vs everyone else, across 6 Square markets · GHL sub-account nYnvjp6gNOEPRj4yDuAU

SIGNAL: NEGATIVE

On the fairest like-for-like comparison — recent sales that were worked by outreach vs recent sales that slipped past it — worked customers reach their crucial 2nd payment 35.6% of the time vs 39.1% for the un-worked group (-3.5 pp). The lift is strongest in New York (-0 pp). Florida currently runs the other way (-6 pp) and needs a look. Sample sizes are still maturing (only 1659 outreach customers have had their 2nd payment fall due), so treat this as a directional early read, not a final verdict. Against the much older pre-outreach baseline outreach looks lower — expected, because outreach customers are far newer and earlier in their payment lifecycle.

1st payment made
50.4%
vs 53.8% recent not-worked · -3.5 pp
1st + 2nd payment made
35.6%
vs 39.1% recent not-worked · -3.5 pp
Collection rate
39.7%
vs 43.6% recent not-worked · -3.9 pp
Chargeback rate
3.1%
vs 3.3% recent not-worked · -0.2 pp

Headline cards compare the Outreach cohort against Recent, not-worked customers — the tenure-matched control (both started after outreach began). "pp" = percentage points. Lower is better for chargebacks.

How to read this. Outreach only started recently and only on new finance sales, so a naïve comparison against all old customers would be unfair. We use three cohorts per market:

Payment rates are age-gated: a customer only counts toward "1st payment made" once their 1st invoice is actually due, so young outreach customers aren't penalised for invoices that haven't come around yet.

1 · Fairest read — Outreach vs Recent sales that slipped past outreach

Both cohorts started after outreach began, so tenure is matched · the only difference is whether they were worked

CohortCustomers 1st pay %Δ 1st+2nd %Δ Collection On track1-2 miss3+/never
Outreach (treated) 2,137 50.4%
967/1920
▼ -3.5 pp 35.6%
590/1659
▼ -3.5 pp 39.7% 901 525 469
Recent, not worked 4,405 53.8%
1937/3598
39.1%
1217/3113
43.6% 1835 987 711

Δ = outreach minus recent-not-worked, in percentage points. Green = outreach ahead. Both groups are recent, so tenure is matched. Outreach 2nd-payment sample n=1659, control n=3113.

2 · Before vs After — Outreach vs the older pre-outreach baseline

Same markets, customers who started before outreach began · NOT tenure-matched — read with care

CohortCustomers 1st pay %Δ 1st+2nd %Δ Collection On track1-2 miss3+/never
Outreach (treated) 2,137 50.4%
967/1920
▼ -3.4 pp 35.6%
590/1659
▼ -5.7 pp 39.7% 901 525 469
Pre-outreach baseline 18,361 53.7%
9827/18283
41.2%
7198/17458
43.4% 7411 2010 8411

Δ = outreach minus baseline. The baseline is far more tenured (avg customer is months further into their plan), so a lower outreach number here mostly reflects recency, not worse performance — which is exactly why Section 1 is the primary read.

3 · Side-by-side — Outreach vs everyone else (all other finance customers)

The literal "those people vs everyone else" — note the baseline skews older

CohortCustomers 1st pay %Δ 1st+2nd %Δ Collection On track1-2 miss3+/never
Outreach (treated) 2,137 50.4%
967/1920
▼ -3.4 pp 35.6%
590/1659
▼ -5.3 pp 39.7% 901 525 469
Everyone else 22,766 53.8%
11764/21881
40.9%
8415/20571
43.4% 9246 2997 9122

4 · Refunds & Chargebacks by cohort

Since each market's outreach start · attributed to the customer's recurring series

CohortCustomers RefundedRefund %Refund $ ChargebacksCB %CB $
Outreach (treated) 2,137 21 1.0% $5,788.75 66 3.1% $27,503.29
Pre-outreach baseline 18,361 188 1.0% $24,128.54 208 1.1% $63,163.54
Recent, not worked 4,405 45 1.0% $17,244.79 146 3.3% $66,749.22

Refund = voluntary (business-initiated, /v2/refunds). Chargeback = customer/bank dispute (/v2/disputes). Account totals this window: 3,507 refunds, 872 chargebacks (some land on non-recurring customers and aren't shown per-cohort).

5 · By market — where outreach is (and isn't) working

Outreach vs recent-not-worked, on the 2nd-payment metric, per Square account

Market Outreach n1st %1st+2nd % Recent nRecent 1st+2nd %Δ 2nd pay
Chicago
outreach from 2026-03-27
294 50.0% 35.2%
87/247
747 39.7%
200/504
▼ -4.5 pp
Boston
outreach from 2026-04-30
108 58.2% 41.3%
31/75
571 45.1%
185/410
▼ -3.8 pp
New York
outreach from 2026-03-27
320 45.0% 31.0%
81/261
630 31.1%
136/437
▼ -0.1 pp
Florida
outreach from 2026-04-13
448 53.4% 34.9%
110/315
1070 40.7%
319/783
▼ -5.8 pp
Texas (Houston + Dallas)
outreach from 2026-04-15
715 48.9% 35.7%
198/554
946 37.2%
254/682
▼ -1.5 pp
Nashville
outreach from 2026-05-04
252 53.3% 40.1%
83/207
441 41.4%
123/297
▼ -1.3 pp

Δ = outreach 2nd-payment % minus recent-not-worked, where both samples are large enough to read. Outreach start dates differ per market. Markets with very few matured 2nd payments show "low n" and shouldn't be over-read.