Every recurring instalment charged since Jan 2026, sorted into buckets, month by month. Built 2026-11-17 15:09 UTC.
Recurring only. Studio-counter, deposit and office declines are excluded from every number on this page — a card failing at the till is a sale that did not go through, not arrears. Read the percentage, not the count. Two kinds of table here, and they answer different questions. Where the bucket is a property of the charge (plan position, payment history, card, issuer) the figure is the decline rate — declines divided by charges inside that same bucket and month, so a bucket getting bigger cannot read as a bucket getting worse. Where the bucket only exists on a decline (the bank's reason code) there is no such rate, so the figure is that reason's share of the month's declines and the label says so. Colour is the rate: under 45%, 45–55%, over 55%. The number is the count and the white figure beside it is the rate.
The issuer's decline code folded into the action it implies — the same five buckets the GHL sequence branches on. MAXED is TRANSACTION_LIMIT, which is not a per-charge cap: in practice the card is at its limit, and we see it on $25 charges. MAXED Card is at its limit — needs a different card or a re-present after payday. RETRY No money in the account right now — worth re-presenting. NEW_CARD The card is dead — expired, closed or the number is wrong. CALL_BANK The issuer has blocked this kind of charge — the customer must call them. RE_KEY Card details entered wrong — re-key them. CHASE No reason given by the bank — treat as a normal chase.
| Month | MAXED | CHASE | CALL_BANK | RETRY | NEW_CARD | RE_KEY |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| Jan 2026 | 1,927 40.7% | 1,687 35.6% | 419 8.9% | 445 9.4% | 255 5.4% | — |
| Feb 2026 | 1,925 39.3% | 1,799 36.7% | 457 9.3% | 440 9.0% | 276 5.6% | — |
| Mar 2026 | 2,066 39.6% | 1,955 37.5% | 489 9.4% | 407 7.8% | 300 5.7% | 2 0.0% |
| Apr 2026 | 2,061 37.8% | 2,006 36.8% | 575 10.6% | 477 8.8% | 331 6.1% | — |
| May 2026 | 2,215 38.8% | 2,051 35.9% | 607 10.6% | 500 8.8% | 337 5.9% | 1 0.0% |
| Jun 2026 | 2,326 38.8% | 2,141 35.7% | 650 10.8% | 507 8.4% | 378 6.3% | — |
| Jul 2026 | 2,346 38.4% | 2,158 35.3% | 664 10.9% | 524 8.6% | 423 6.9% | — |
| Aug 2026 | 2,354 37.7% | 2,192 35.1% | 635 10.2% | 598 9.6% | 458 7.3% | 2 0.0% |
| Sept 2026 | 2,355 37.7% | 2,163 34.7% | 680 10.9% | 568 9.1% | 471 7.5% | 2 0.0% |
| Oct 2026 | 2,281 37.2% | 2,214 36.1% | 624 10.2% | 576 9.4% | 431 7.0% | 1 0.0% |
| Nov 2026 | 973 35.5% | 1,049 38.2% | 267 9.7% | 292 10.6% | 163 5.9% | — |
| TOTAL | 22,829 38.4% | 21,415 36.0% | 6,067 10.2% | 5,334 9.0% | 3,823 6.4% | 8 0.0% |
The code underneath the action above, unfolded. Watch the split between the codes that mean no money (TRANSACTION_LIMIT, INSUFFICIENT_FUNDS) and the ones that mean the card is dead or blocked (INVALID_ACCOUNT, CARD_EXPIRED, PAN_FAILURE, CARDHOLDER_INSUFFICIENT_PERMISSIONS): the first is the economy, the second is something we can fix by getting a new card on file.
| Month | TRANSACTION_LIMIT | GENERIC_DECLINE | INSUFFICIENT_FUNDS | CARDHOLDER_INSUFFICIENT_PERMISSIONS | INVALID_ACCOUNT | CARD_EXPIRED | PAN_FAILURE | ISSUER_INSTALLMENT_ERROR | EXPIRATION_FAILURE | CVV_FAILURE | PAYMENT_LIMIT_EXCEEDED | NO_REASON_GIVEN | INSUFFICIENT_PERMISSIONS | ADDRESS_VERIFICATION_FAILURE |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| Jan 2026 | 1,926 40.7% | 1,686 35.6% | 445 9.4% | 371 7.8% | 106 2.2% | 94 2.0% | 48 1.0% | 48 1.0% | 7 0.1% | — | 1 0.0% | 1 0.0% | — | — |
| Feb 2026 | 1,925 39.3% | 1,798 36.7% | 440 9.0% | 407 8.3% | 116 2.4% | 95 1.9% | 58 1.2% | 50 1.0% | 7 0.1% | — | — | 1 0.0% | — | — |
| Mar 2026 | 2,065 39.6% | 1,954 37.4% | 407 7.8% | 430 8.2% | 123 2.4% | 102 2.0% | 70 1.3% | 59 1.1% | 5 0.1% | 1 0.0% | 1 0.0% | 1 0.0% | — | 1 0.0% |
| Apr 2026 | 2,061 37.8% | 2,006 36.8% | 477 8.8% | 512 9.4% | 153 2.8% | 103 1.9% | 71 1.3% | 63 1.2% | 4 0.1% | — | — | — | — | — |
| May 2026 | 2,213 38.7% | 2,050 35.9% | 500 8.8% | 546 9.6% | 158 2.8% | 103 1.8% | 70 1.2% | 61 1.1% | 6 0.1% | 1 0.0% | 2 0.0% | 1 0.0% | — | — |
| Jun 2026 | 2,326 38.8% | 2,141 35.7% | 507 8.4% | 586 9.8% | 165 2.7% | 114 1.9% | 95 1.6% | 64 1.1% | 4 0.1% | — | — | — | — | — |
| Jul 2026 | 2,346 38.4% | 2,156 35.3% | 524 8.6% | 602 9.8% | 201 3.3% | 118 1.9% | 104 1.7% | 62 1.0% | — | — | — | — | 2 0.0% | — |
| Aug 2026 | 2,353 37.7% | 2,191 35.1% | 598 9.6% | 515 8.3% | 226 3.6% | 119 1.9% | 113 1.8% | 120 1.9% | — | 2 0.0% | 1 0.0% | 1 0.0% | — | — |
| Sept 2026 | 2,354 37.7% | 2,162 34.7% | 568 9.1% | 529 8.5% | 187 3.0% | 158 2.5% | 121 1.9% | 151 2.4% | 5 0.1% | 2 0.0% | 1 0.0% | 1 0.0% | — | — |
| Oct 2026 | 2,281 37.2% | 2,214 36.1% | 576 9.4% | 482 7.9% | 168 2.7% | 133 2.2% | 123 2.0% | 142 2.3% | 7 0.1% | 1 0.0% | — | — | — | — |
| Nov 2026 | 973 35.5% | 1,049 38.2% | 292 10.6% | 213 7.8% | 78 2.8% | 37 1.3% | 45 1.6% | 54 2.0% | 3 0.1% | — | — | — | — | — |
| TOTAL | 22,823 38.4% | 21,407 36.0% | 5,334 9.0% | 5,193 8.7% | 1,681 2.8% | 1,176 2.0% | 918 1.5% | 874 1.5% | 48 0.1% | 7 0.0% | 6 0.0% | 6 0.0% | 2 0.0% | 1 0.0% |
An agreement is a run of recurring charges; a new one starts after 12 months of silence from that customer — the same test /first-payments and /instalment-recovery use. History is read from June 2023, so a charge in Jan 2026 has two and a half years of visibility behind it and cannot be mistaken for an opening.
The rise down this table is NOT proof that people get worse over time. It is heavily
survivorship-biased: someone who pays cleanly finishes their plan and leaves the book, so the further into a
plan you look, the more the remaining population is the people who were already struggling. The honest reading
is "a charge deep in a plan is far more likely to fail than an opening charge" — useful for
deciding where to put effort — not "plans decay". Separating those two needs a fixed cohort
followed forward, which is what /instalment-recovery does.
| Month | 1st | 2nd | 3rd–6th | 7th–12th | 13th+ |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| Jan 2026 | 401 47.2% | 385 45.6% | 1,869 56.8% | 1,337 50.2% | 741 61.2% |
| Feb 2026 | 357 43.3% | 341 42.6% | 1,844 56.3% | 1,551 53.3% | 804 61.3% |
| Mar 2026 | 399 43.2% | 301 37.5% | 1,779 55.2% | 1,810 57.6% | 930 63.7% |
| Apr 2026 | 488 47.7% | 361 42.7% | 1,613 53.3% | 1,972 59.3% | 1,016 65.8% |
| May 2026 | 417 50.7% | 479 49.4% | 1,634 54.0% | 2,059 60.5% | 1,122 66.9% |
| Jun 2026 | 486 49.0% | 412 48.5% | 1,737 55.0% | 2,243 62.5% | 1,124 67.9% |
| Jul 2026 | 414 43.7% | 410 46.1% | 1,808 56.5% | 2,247 62.6% | 1,236 69.2% |
| Aug 2026 | 467 48.0% | 399 44.4% | 1,877 57.9% | 2,166 63.4% | 1,330 71.4% |
| Sept 2026 | 441 48.8% | 410 45.7% | 1,794 56.6% | 2,087 62.3% | 1,507 75.4% |
| Oct 2026 | 405 47.9% | 412 47.5% | 1,757 55.7% | 2,013 59.8% | 1,540 75.9% |
| Nov 2026 | 147 46.5% | 168 47.1% | 727 53.4% | 961 56.9% | 741 72.9% |
| TOTAL | 4,422 46.9% | 4,078 45.2% | 18,439 55.7% | 20,446 59.3% | 12,091 68.9% |
The share of their own agreement they had already paid at the moment of that charge — never with hindsight, or every decline would look like it came from a bad payer. First charge is the opening instalment, which has no history behind it yet.
| Month | First charge | Never paid | Paid under half | Paid 50–80% | Paid 80%+ |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| Jan 2026 | 401 47.2% | 1,333 84.9% | 1,614 75.7% | 984 54.1% | 401 16.1% |
| Feb 2026 | 357 43.3% | 1,414 85.5% | 1,746 74.0% | 973 53.4% | 407 16.5% |
| Mar 2026 | 399 43.2% | 1,520 86.7% | 1,955 76.5% | 972 52.5% | 373 15.1% |
| Apr 2026 | 488 47.7% | 1,578 88.5% | 2,022 78.3% | 979 52.9% | 383 15.2% |
| May 2026 | 417 50.7% | 1,769 89.8% | 2,115 79.0% | 975 52.9% | 435 16.8% |
| Jun 2026 | 486 49.0% | 1,930 88.9% | 2,195 80.6% | 973 53.0% | 418 16.6% |
| Jul 2026 | 414 43.7% | 2,041 90.5% | 2,226 80.0% | 1,022 54.3% | 412 16.2% |
| Aug 2026 | 467 48.0% | 2,061 90.2% | 2,280 82.7% | 982 54.7% | 449 17.4% |
| Sept 2026 | 441 48.8% | 2,033 90.0% | 2,366 83.4% | 978 55.6% | 421 16.5% |
| Oct 2026 | 405 47.9% | 1,906 87.8% | 2,420 83.6% | 951 53.4% | 445 17.3% |
| Nov 2026 | 147 46.5% | 802 89.1% | 1,126 80.5% | 463 52.9% | 206 16.5% |
| TOTAL | 4,422 46.9% | 18,387 88.5% | 22,065 79.6% | 10,252 53.6% | 4,350 16.4% |
The card and issuer tables below can only see charges that carry a BIN, which comes from a separate pull with its own window. A month with low coverage here is not a month with no prepaid cards — it is a month the feed has not reached. Charges with no BIN are excluded from those two tables rather than bucketed as unknown.
| Month | Recurring charges | With a BIN |
|---|---|---|
| Jan 2026 | 8,862 | 8,840 99.8% |
| Feb 2026 | 9,124 | 9,094 99.7% |
| Mar 2026 | 9,553 | 9,525 99.7% |
| Apr 2026 | 9,763 | 9,739 99.8% |
| May 2026 | 9,897 | 9,874 99.8% |
| Jun 2026 | 10,244 | 10,221 99.8% |
| Jul 2026 | 10,411 | 10,396 99.9% |
| Aug 2026 | 10,394 | 10,378 99.8% |
| Sept 2026 | 10,318 | 10,295 99.8% |
| Oct 2026 | 10,261 | 10,242 99.8% |
| Nov 2026 | 4,741 | 1,005 21.2% |
Prepaid wins over debit/credit where a card is both — a prepaid debit card behaves like prepaid, not like debit. Card type comes from Square per card where it has one, and falls back to the BIN reference.
| Month | Prepaid | Debit | Credit |
|---|---|---|---|
| Jan 2026 | 709 81.8% | 3,282 54.6% | 741 37.7% |
| Feb 2026 | 753 81.6% | 3,361 54.7% | 782 38.6% |
| Mar 2026 | 824 81.2% | 3,556 55.4% | 838 40.0% |
| Apr 2026 | 851 82.8% | 3,754 56.9% | 845 40.0% |
| May 2026 | 901 84.9% | 3,930 58.7% | 879 41.5% |
| Jun 2026 | 936 83.8% | 4,147 59.8% | 919 42.5% |
| Jul 2026 | 938 84.6% | 4,212 59.8% | 965 43.0% |
| Aug 2026 | 966 85.8% | 4,280 61.2% | 992 44.0% |
| Sept 2026 | 926 86.1% | 4,298 62.2% | 1,014 44.0% |
| Oct 2026 | 920 85.3% | 4,205 60.7% | 1,002 44.7% |
| Nov 2026 | 89 80.2% | 381 58.1% | 88 37.0% |
| TOTAL | 8,813 83.8% | 39,406 58.5% | 9,065 41.6% |
Read this one carefully. A BIN identifies the ISSUER, not the cardholder. "Early-access neobank" is the sponsor-bank cluster behind Cash App, Chime, Current, Varo, Dave, SoFi and MoneyLion — the population that can be paid wages early, not a proven list of people who are. "Benefits card" is Direct Express, the federal benefits debit card Comerica issues: that population is paid on the 1st and 3rd and on a Wednesday set by birth date, not on a payroll Friday, so it was split out of "traditional bank" on 4 Sep 2026 rather than being averaged in with Chase and Wells Fargo. Two banks changed side that day too: SoFi and Choice Financial Group (Current's sponsor) were being counted as traditional and are early-access.
| Month | Early-access neobank | Benefits card (Direct Express) | Traditional bank / credit union | Unknown issuer |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Jan 2026 | 1,282 80.8% | 30 76.9% | 3,420 47.4% | 0 0.0% |
| Feb 2026 | 1,346 79.9% | 29 82.9% | 3,521 47.8% | 0 0.0% |
| Mar 2026 | 1,489 80.7% | 27 79.4% | 3,702 48.4% | 0 0.0% |
| Apr 2026 | 1,575 83.3% | 30 75.0% | 3,845 49.3% | 0 0.0% |
| May 2026 | 1,676 85.0% | 36 73.5% | 3,998 50.9% | 0 0.0% |
| Jun 2026 | 1,747 84.6% | 40 70.2% | 4,215 52.1% | 0 0.0% |
| Jul 2026 | 1,763 84.7% | 34 66.7% | 4,318 52.3% | 0 0.0% |
| Aug 2026 | 1,766 86.1% | 37 72.5% | 4,435 53.7% | 0 0.0% |
| Sept 2026 | 1,727 87.0% | 38 73.1% | 4,471 54.3% | 2 11.1% |
| Oct 2026 | 1,666 86.0% | 40 81.6% | 4,410 53.8% | 11 17.5% |
| Nov 2026 | 156 83.9% | 6 50.0% | 394 49.7% | 2 14.3% |
| TOTAL | 16,193 84.0% | 347 74.0% | 40,729 51.1% | 15 10.6% |
The table above sorts banks into two boxes. This one names them. Same recurring charges, cut by the name printed on the card, 300+ charges since Jan 2026 to qualify — 46 banks, 79,729 charges — 77.0% of the 103,568 on the book, out of the 99,467 we can name an issuer for at all (the rest are spread thinly across 1,020 smaller banks and credit unions, all of them in the CSV). The figure is the share that went through, so it reads the same way round as the money beside it. “Charges” is attempts, not people — the People column is how many customers those charges belong to and the multiplier is how many times we hit each one. Every bank, including the ones under 300, is in the CSV.
The 8 worst banks on the book are early-access, but the break is no longer clean: M&T BANK at 23.7% now sits below the best early-access bank, COASTAL COMMUNITY BANK at 28.4%.
| Issuing bank | Class | Went through | Charges | People | Prepaid | Asked for | Collected |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| GREEN DOT BANK DBA BONNEVILLE BANK | Early-access | 119 9.6% | 1,245 | 166 7.5× | 0 0.0% | $247,433 | $14,676 5.9% |
| SUTTON BANK | Early-access | 1,045 12.5% | 8,355 | 1,412 5.9× | 8,172 97.8% | $1,448,847 | $172,443 11.9% |
| THE BANCORP BANK NATIONAL ASSOCIATION | Early-access | 184 16.6% | 1,108 | 204 5.4× | 27 2.4% | $202,081 | $30,409 15.0% |
| THE BANCORP BANK | Early-access | 519 18.7% | 2,773 | 494 5.6× | 167 6.0% | $460,142 | $76,758 16.7% |
| STRIDE BANK | Early-access | 499 19.5% | 2,562 | 449 5.7× | 7 0.3% | $443,761 | $73,029 16.5% |
| PATHWARD | Early-access | 124 21.3% | 582 | 103 5.7× | 302 51.9% | $137,746 | $19,800 14.4% |
| EVOLVE BANK & TRUST | Early-access | 121 21.8% | 554 | 96 5.8× | 25 4.5% | $104,781 | $24,351 23.2% |
| SOFI BANK | Early-access | 151 23.0% | 657 | 115 5.7× | 0 0.0% | $135,137 | $32,520 24.1% |
| M&T BANK | Traditional | 98 23.7% | 414 | 49 8.4× | 0 0.0% | $80,016 | $19,231 24.0% |
| COMERICA BANK | Benefits | 122 26.0% | 469 | 68 6.9× | 438 93.4% | $71,565 | $14,719 20.6% |
| SANTANDER BANK | Traditional | 196 26.8% | 730 | 104 7.0× | 0 0.0% | $144,711 | $39,053 27.0% |
| COASTAL COMMUNITY BANK | Early-access | 99 28.4% | 349 | 66 5.3× | 0 0.0% | $58,410 | $18,235 31.2% |
| MUNICIPAL CREDIT UNION | Traditional | 112 30.2% | 371 | 43 8.6× | 0 0.0% | $65,605 | $19,682 30.0% |
| FIRST NATIONAL BANK TEXAS | Traditional | 209 31.6% | 661 | 99 6.7× | 0 0.0% | $136,771 | $41,873 30.6% |
| USAA FEDERAL SAVINGS BANK | Traditional | 524 34.9% | 1,501 | 200 7.5× | 0 0.0% | $346,016 | $115,200 33.3% |
| CREDIT ONE BANK | Traditional | 182 35.0% | 520 | 111 4.7× | 0 0.0% | $97,001 | $31,545 32.5% |
| NAVY FEDERAL CREDIT UNION | Traditional | 1,383 35.9% | 3,853 | 672 5.7× | 0 0.0% | $808,559 | $288,457 35.7% |
| WOODFOREST NATIONAL BANK | Traditional | 173 38.6% | 448 | 70 6.4× | 0 0.0% | $95,291 | $37,126 39.0% |
| HUNTINGTON NATIONAL BANK | Traditional | 151 39.5% | 382 | 73 5.2× | 0 0.0% | $68,351 | $25,058 36.7% |
| BMO BANK NATIONAL ASSOCIATION | Traditional | 119 39.7% | 300 | 54 5.6× | 0 0.0% | $55,435 | $18,139 32.7% |
| DIGITAL FEDERAL CREDIT UNION | Traditional | 152 40.4% | 376 | 85 4.4× | 0 0.0% | $75,368 | $28,372 37.6% |
| U.S. BANK NATIONAL ASSOCIATION | Traditional | 311 40.7% | 765 | 148 5.2× | 174 22.7% | $131,188 | $53,116 40.5% |
| FISERV SOLUTIONS | Traditional | 227 42.0% | 540 | 95 5.7× | 0 0.0% | $106,983 | $42,636 39.9% |
| TD BANK | Traditional | 1,001 42.2% | 2,374 | 419 5.7× | 4 0.2% | $485,028 | $195,948 40.4% |
| PNC BANK | Traditional | 724 44.0% | 1,646 | 323 5.1× | 0 0.0% | $333,346 | $147,926 44.4% |
| FIFTH THIRD BANK | Traditional | 358 44.5% | 804 | 154 5.2× | 20 2.5% | $157,447 | $66,958 42.5% |
| WELLS FARGO BANK | Traditional | 2,428 44.6% | 5,440 | 1,079 5.0× | 16 0.3% | $1,145,695 | $480,287 41.9% |
| REGIONS BANK | Traditional | 540 44.8% | 1,206 | 224 5.4× | 79 6.6% | $238,742 | $107,861 45.2% |
| SUNCOAST CREDIT UNION | Traditional | 151 45.2% | 334 | 57 5.9× | 0 0.0% | $69,964 | $31,878 45.6% |
| CITIZENS BANK | Traditional | 440 47.2% | 932 | 168 5.5× | 0 0.0% | $161,350 | $76,695 47.5% |
| TRUIST BANK | Traditional | 499 49.6% | 1,006 | 188 5.4× | 7 0.7% | $206,455 | $102,649 49.7% |
| BANK OF AMERICA | Traditional | 4,617 50.0% | 9,226 | 1,721 5.4× | 1 0.0% | $1,826,084 | $901,681 49.4% |
| DISCOVER ISSUER | Traditional | 2,162 50.2% | 4,303 | 822 5.2× | 0 0.0% | $853,369 | $419,710 49.2% |
| RANDOLPH BROOKS FEDERAL CREDIT UNION | Traditional | 189 51.1% | 370 | 59 6.3× | 0 0.0% | $72,052 | $37,443 52.0% |
| CAPITAL ONE | Traditional | 2,342 51.1% | 4,584 | 897 5.1× | 0 0.0% | $955,988 | $478,322 50.0% |
| JACK HENRY & ASSOCIATES | Traditional | 158 51.8% | 305 | 54 5.6× | 0 0.0% | $75,628 | $34,732 45.9% |
| JPMORGAN CHASE BANK N.A. - DEBIT | Traditional | 4,739 53.0% | 8,939 | 1,705 5.2× | 0 0.0% | $1,790,465 | $906,128 50.6% |
| SYNCHRONY BANK | Traditional | 205 57.4% | 357 | 72 5.0× | 0 0.0% | $79,737 | $44,119 55.3% |
| CITIBANK N.A. | Traditional | 829 59.6% | 1,391 | 266 5.2× | 0 0.0% | $292,018 | $173,206 59.3% |
| U.S. BANK NATIONAL ASSOCIATION-CREDIT | Traditional | 252 61.0% | 413 | 73 5.7× | 0 0.0% | $80,019 | $48,578 60.7% |
| BARCLAYS BANK DELAWARE | Traditional | 206 67.1% | 307 | 62 5.0× | 0 0.0% | $68,128 | $46,033 67.6% |
| GOLDMAN SACHS BANK USA | Traditional | 305 68.4% | 446 | 98 4.6× | 0 0.0% | $96,913 | $61,229 63.2% |
| AMERICAN EXPRESS US CONSUMER | Traditional | 900 69.1% | 1,302 | 275 4.7× | 0 0.0% | $304,300 | $206,078 67.7% |
| BANK OF AMERICA - CONSUMER CREDIT | Traditional | 996 72.2% | 1,379 | 300 4.6× | 0 0.0% | $303,116 | $216,724 71.5% |
| CITIBANK | Traditional | 286 74.5% | 384 | 78 4.9× | 0 0.0% | $84,656 | $62,256 73.5% |
| JPMORGAN CHASE BANK N.A. | Traditional | 2,137 77.3% | 2,766 | 566 4.9× | 0 0.0% | $598,522 | $453,276 75.7% |
The obvious explanation for the table above is the plastic: prepaid cards have no overdraft, so of course they bounce. The data does not support it. Hold the bank constant and vary the card format, and the format barely moves the number; hold the format constant and vary the bank, and the number halves.
| Bank the customer chose | Normal card — went through | Prepaid card — went through |
|---|---|---|
| Early-access neobank | 1,937 18.5% of 10,498 charges | 1,153 13.1% of 8,785 charges |
| Benefits card (Direct Express) | 24 77.4% of 31 charges | 98 22.4% of 438 charges |
| Traditional bank / credit union | 38,546 49.1% of 78,442 charges | 435 34.2% of 1,273 charges |
A normal, non-prepaid card from an early-access bank went through 18.5% of the time (10,498 charges). A prepaid card from a high-street bank or credit union went through 34.2% of the time (1,273 charges). The prepaid card at the ordinary bank beat the ordinary card at the neobank. And the single worst performer on the book, GREEN DOT BANK DBA BONNEVILLE BANK at 9.6%, is 0.0% prepaid, while SUTTON BANK is 97.8% prepaid and does better at 12.5%. The card format is not what predicts failure. Which bank the customer chose is.
“6,000 charges” reads like 6,000 people. It is not: we charge the same person every month, and a failed charge gets re-presented, so one customer can be a dozen rows. Here are the same banks with the customer count beside the attempt count, and what we asked those customers for against what actually arrived.
| Issuing bank | Class | Charges | People | Went through | Asked for | Collected |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| SUTTON BANK | Early-access | 8,355 | 1,412 5.9× each | 1,045 12.5% | $1,448,847 | $172,443 11.9% |
| JPMORGAN CHASE BANK N.A. - DEBIT | Traditional | 8,939 | 1,705 5.2× each | 4,739 53.0% | $1,790,465 | $906,128 50.6% |
| GREEN DOT BANK DBA BONNEVILLE BANK | Early-access | 1,245 | 166 7.5× each | 119 9.6% | $247,433 | $14,676 5.9% |
| STRIDE BANK | Early-access | 2,562 | 449 5.7× each | 499 19.5% | $443,761 | $73,029 16.5% |
SUTTON BANK and JPMORGAN CHASE BANK N.A. - DEBIT are almost the same size of group — 1,412 people against 1,705 — and we asked them for almost the same money, $1,448,847 against $1,790,465. We collected $172,443 from the first and $906,128 from the second. GREEN DOT BANK DBA BONNEVILLE BANK is smaller — 166 people, 1,245 attempts — but we asked for $247,433 and collected $14,676, 5.9% of it.
If the early-access story were really “these people are paid two days early”, their charges would do best in the middle of the week — Wednesday or Thursday — when the early money has landed and the Friday payroll has not. Every charge below is one that carries an identified card (99,467 of 103,568), grouped by the weekday it was actually charged in the studio's own timezone. The Benefits column is one issuer split seven ways — Comerica, a few hundred charges in total — so every cell under 200 charges is greyed and carries no swing figure. Read the Early-access and Traditional columns; the Benefits one is there for completeness.
| Day charged | Early-access | Benefits | Traditional |
|---|---|---|---|
| Sunday | 270 11.2% of 2,421 charges | 10 19.6% of 51 charges — too few | 4,591 46.6% of 9,858 charges |
| Monday | 432 15.9% of 2,722 charges | 20 28.6% of 70 charges — too few | 5,675 48.9% of 11,617 charges |
| Tuesday | 429 15.8% of 2,719 charges | 17 25.0% of 68 charges — too few | 5,285 47.0% of 11,250 charges |
| Wednesday | 470 16.5% of 2,840 charges | 21 26.6% of 79 charges — too few | 5,537 47.9% of 11,559 charges |
| Thursday | 513 18.8% of 2,735 charges | 18 29.5% of 61 charges — too few | 5,701 50.9% of 11,201 charges |
| Friday | 640 20.6% of 3,106 charges | 19 27.1% of 70 charges — too few | 6,698 53.1% of 12,610 charges |
| Saturday | 336 12.3% of 2,740 charges | 17 24.3% of 70 charges — too few | 5,494 47.3% of 11,620 charges |
| SWING — best day ÷ worst day | 1.8× | — | 1.1× |
Both groups peak on Friday and
both trough on Sunday
— the same shape, so the weekday effect is not something the neobanks have and the high-street banks do not.
What differs is the size of it: early-access swings 1.8×
from its best day to its worst, traditional only 1.1×. These
customers are far more exposed to when in the week we ask.
This is not evidence of the “paid two days early” effect. If it were, the
early-access line would peak mid-week. It peaks on Friday, the same day as everyone else — which
says the money lands on the ordinary payroll cycle and these accounts simply run empty faster afterwards.
No BIN needed for these two, so they cover every one of the 103,568 recurring charges since Jan 2026 — the widest basis on this page, including the days and months the card feed has not reached. The question is whether the days we have chosen to charge on are the days that pay.
| Day of month | Charges | Share of the book | Went through | |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| 1st | 4,226 | 4.1% | 2,061 48.8% | |
| 2nd | 2,599 | 2.5% | 1,250 48.1% | |
| 3rd | 2,798 | 2.7% | 1,202 43.0% | |
| 4th | 2,004 | 1.9% | 954 47.6% | |
| 5th | 3,209 | 3.1% | 1,365 42.5% | |
| 6th | 3,134 | 3.0% | 1,387 44.3% | |
| 7th | 2,025 | 2.0% | 926 45.7% | |
| 8th | 2,068 | 2.0% | 889 43.0% | |
| 9th | 2,365 | 2.3% | 998 42.2% | |
| 10th | 3,832 | 3.7% | 1,688 44.1% | |
| 11th | 2,041 | 2.0% | 898 44.0% | |
| 12th | 2,838 | 2.7% | 1,193 42.0% | |
| 13th | 2,923 | 2.8% | 1,219 41.7% | |
| 14th | 2,394 | 2.3% | 924 38.6% | |
| 15th | 9,253 | 8.9% | 3,998 43.2% | one of our 4 busiest — 20th worst of 30 |
| 16th | 3,593 | 3.5% | 1,678 46.7% | |
| 17th | 3,314 | 3.2% | 1,435 43.3% | |
| 18th | 2,930 | 2.8% | 1,158 39.5% | |
| 19th | 3,028 | 2.9% | 1,212 40.0% | |
| 20th | 4,815 | 4.6% | 1,941 40.3% | one of our 4 busiest — 7th worst of 30 |
| 21st | 2,615 | 2.5% | 1,078 41.2% | |
| 22nd | 2,925 | 2.8% | 1,235 42.2% | |
| 23rd | 2,480 | 2.4% | 1,077 43.4% | |
| 24th | 2,942 | 2.8% | 1,211 41.2% | |
| 25th | 3,462 | 3.3% | 1,442 41.7% | |
| 26th | 2,729 | 2.6% | 1,150 42.1% | |
| 27th | 3,111 | 3.0% | 1,321 42.5% | |
| 28th | 5,803 | 5.6% | 2,294 39.5% | one of our 4 busiest — 4th worst of 30 |
| 29th | 410 | 0.4% | 297 72.4% | too few charges to read |
| 30th | 4,206 | 4.1% | 1,682 40.0% | |
| 31st | 7,496 | 7.2% | 2,914 38.9% | one of our 4 busiest — 2nd worst of 30 |
Best day of the month is the 1st at
48.8%; worst is the 14th at
38.6%.
Our four busiest days — the 15th (20th worst of 30), the 31st (2nd worst of 30), the 28th (4th worst of 30), the 20th (7th worst of 30)
— carry 26.4% of every charge we make.
3 of those four sit in the worse half of the month, and between them the four go through
40.7% of the time against
43.2% on every other day —
2.5 points worse,
on 27,367 charges. We have concentrated the book onto days that pay below average.
The 29th is marked
too few charges to read: 410 charges on the 29th,
against 3,452 on a normal day. The 29th shows
72.4%, which is an artefact of how few agreements are set to that day and which
months even have one — not a good day to charge on. Do not move anything onto it on this evidence.
| Day charged | Charges | Share of the book | Went through |
|---|---|---|---|
| Sunday | 13,414 | 13.0% | 5,330 39.7% |
| Monday | 15,045 | 14.5% | 6,420 42.7% |
| Tuesday | 14,550 | 14.0% | 5,946 40.9% |
| Wednesday | 14,733 | 14.2% | 6,179 41.9% |
| Thursday | 14,556 | 14.1% | 6,479 44.5% |
| Friday | 16,455 | 15.9% | 7,700 46.8% |
| Saturday | 14,815 | 14.3% | 6,023 40.7% |
Friday is the best day to ask at 46.8% and Sunday the worst at 39.7% — 7.1 points between them on the whole book. Saturday and Sunday together take 27.3% of every charge we make, and both sit below the weekday average. Nothing about a weekend charge is cheaper for us to attempt.
Ranked by total declines over the whole period, so the columns stay in one order down the months. Issuers outside the top 12 are in the CSV, not dropped.
| Month | SUTTON BANK | BANK OF AMERICA | JPMORGAN CHASE BANK N.A. - DEBIT | WELLS FARGO BANK | NAVY FEDERAL CREDIT UNION | THE BANCORP BANK | CAPITAL ONE | DISCOVER ISSUER | STRIDE BANK | TD BANK | GREEN DOT BANK DBA BONNEVILLE BANK | USAA FEDERAL SAVINGS BANK |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| Jan 2026 | 585 86.4% | 399 45.1% | 354 44.0% | 277 53.8% | 191 59.3% | 176 76.2% | 203 47.5% | 142 43.0% | 164 76.3% | 130 51.6% | 85 85.9% | 75 56.8% |
| Feb 2026 | 629 84.7% | 401 46.7% | 363 44.3% | 278 53.0% | 197 60.8% | 183 75.0% | 211 50.1% | 154 44.0% | 154 73.0% | 126 51.2% | 99 89.2% | 86 63.7% |
| Mar 2026 | 693 84.9% | 406 46.6% | 375 44.3% | 285 52.8% | 213 60.5% | 212 78.5% | 224 50.8% | 179 46.0% | 182 76.8% | 125 51.7% | 96 88.1% | 88 67.2% |
| Apr 2026 | 720 86.3% | 422 48.1% | 405 46.8% | 289 52.9% | 222 58.9% | 226 81.9% | 213 47.1% | 195 47.7% | 192 81.4% | 133 55.6% | 106 87.6% | 82 60.3% |
| May 2026 | 766 88.9% | 442 49.9% | 443 49.7% | 294 55.9% | 240 61.7% | 219 81.1% | 198 44.1% | 206 48.7% | 210 82.0% | 133 56.6% | 129 92.1% | 97 65.1% |
| Jun 2026 | 774 87.6% | 481 52.0% | 427 47.3% | 300 55.7% | 249 65.7% | 230 79.3% | 222 46.8% | 233 51.2% | 237 82.6% | 147 60.7% | 131 94.2% | 115 72.3% |
| Jul 2026 | 780 87.2% | 495 52.2% | 434 46.7% | 307 56.1% | 264 66.5% | 242 82.6% | 238 49.9% | 248 51.5% | 243 82.7% | 136 59.4% | 134 91.2% | 110 68.3% |
| Aug 2026 | 799 89.7% | 512 52.2% | 441 47.7% | 316 57.4% | 278 67.1% | 250 85.6% | 245 51.0% | 262 54.2% | 229 83.3% | 147 63.4% | 115 89.8% | 111 66.5% |
| Sept 2026 | 760 90.2% | 524 54.7% | 454 49.0% | 318 59.1% | 292 70.5% | 259 85.2% | 240 50.7% | 242 50.7% | 219 81.4% | 145 65.0% | 106 93.0% | 107 65.6% |
| Oct 2026 | 733 88.2% | 486 50.9% | 465 49.2% | 316 56.9% | 292 67.9% | 242 84.6% | 227 50.4% | 266 56.2% | 213 83.2% | 139 64.4% | 110 92.4% | 94 63.1% |
| Nov 2026 | 71 89.9% | 37 44.0% | 39 46.4% | 31 53.4% | 32 58.2% | 15 88.2% | 21 52.5% | 14 43.8% | 20 76.9% | 12 66.7% | 15 83.3% | 12 63.2% |
| TOTAL | 7,310 87.5% | 4,605 49.9% | 4,200 47.0% | 3,011 55.3% | 2,470 64.1% | 2,254 81.3% | 2,242 48.9% | 2,141 49.8% | 2,063 80.5% | 1,373 57.8% | 1,126 90.4% | 977 65.1% |
Every bucket this page groups by is reachable from one of these three.