Share:

Card types - debit vs credit, and what declines

2026-08-01 to 2026-10-31 · 46,557 card attempts across 6 Square accounts / 29 locations · data on file 2026-08-01 to 2026-10-31 · built 2026-11-17 15:03 UTC · download the full cross-tab CSV
873 payments in this window carried no card details at all (cash / external / wallet tenders, $66,910 taken). They have no card type to report and are excluded from every table below.
Card payments taken
24,554
$6,014,914
Debit - share of value
55.9%
16,640 payments / $3.36M
Credit - share of value
44.1%
7,914 payments / $2.66M
Debit decline rate
51.8%
vs 34.2% on credit
Prepaid payments
1,368
5.6% of all / $190k
Value declined
$5.58M
22,000 failed attempts
Debit vs credit vs unknown

Every card attempt Square recorded across all 6 merchant accounts and 29 locations between 2026-08-01 and 2026-10-31, deduplicated by payment id. Payments taken = status COMPLETED. Decline rate = FAILED divided by (FAILED + COMPLETED); cancelled and still-authorised attempts are left out of the rate. UNKNOWN is the issuer's own answer - Square could not classify the BIN - not a gap in this report.

Card typePayments takenValue taken Avg paymentCustomers Decline rateValue declined
DEBIT 16,640 67.8% $3,359,707 55.9% $201.91 11,831 51.8% 17,885/34,525 $4.11M
CREDIT 7,914 32.2% $2,655,207 44.1% $335.51 5,542 34.2% 4,115/12,029 $1.46M
UNKNOWN 0 0.0% $0 0.0% - 0 - 0/0 $0
TOTAL 24,554 $6,014,914 $244.97 17,060 47.3% $5.58M
The answer: 67.8% of the card payments we take are debit and 32.2% are credit (0.0% unknown). By value it is 55.9% debit / 44.1% credit - average debit payment $201.91 against $335.51 on credit.
Debit declines MORE than credit: 51.8% vs 34.2% - a 17.6pt penalty, 1.51x. Across 34,525 debit attempts that is roughly 6,074 extra failures in the window than if debit behaved like credit.
Prepaid: 4,434 attempts (9.5% of all), $190,364 taken, declining at 69.1% against 45.0% on funded cards. Prepaid is materially worse and is worth its own collections rule.
Where the money comes from - by city
CityPayments takenValue taken Avg paymentCustomers Decline rateValue declined
Texas 6,457 26.3% $1,564,631 26.0% $242.32 4,428 50.7% 6,633/13,090 $1.59M
Florida 5,316 21.7% $1,456,543 24.2% $273.99 3,804 42.1% 3,858/9,174 $1.14M
New York 3,792 15.4% $879,615 14.6% $231.97 2,659 52.8% 4,245/8,037 $1.04M
Chicago 3,379 13.8% $859,517 14.3% $254.37 2,381 43.1% 2,560/5,939 $731k
Nashville 2,845 11.6% $644,237 10.7% $226.45 1,886 47.4% 2,560/5,405 $569k
Boston 2,765 11.3% $610,371 10.1% $220.75 1,902 43.7% 2,144/4,909 $511k
TOTAL 24,554 $6,014,914 $244.97 17,060 47.3% $5.58M
Month by month
MonthPayments takenValue taken Avg paymentCustomers Decline rateValue declined
2026-08 8,512 34.7% $2,095,584 34.8% $246.19 8,170 46.7% 7,469/15,981 $1.94M
2026-09 7,972 32.5% $1,868,164 31.1% $234.34 7,733 48.1% 7,376/15,348 $1.76M
2026-10 8,070 32.9% $2,051,165 34.1% $254.17 7,818 47.0% 7,155/15,225 $1.87M
TOTAL 24,554 $6,014,914 $244.97 17,060 47.3% $5.58M
By card brand

Sorted by payments taken. Same columns as every other table on this report.

BrandPayments takenValue taken Avg paymentCustomers Decline rateValue declined
VISA 15,967 65.0% $3,843,119 63.9% $240.69 11,359 48.5% 15,064/31,031 $3.79M
MASTERCARD 6,619 27.0% $1,576,371 26.2% $238.16 4,636 46.5% 5,742/12,361 $1.42M
DISCOVER 1,208 4.9% $276,586 4.6% $228.96 819 43.5% 931/2,139 $273k
AMERICAN_EXPRESS 759 3.1% $318,788 5.3% $420.01 569 25.7% 263/1,022 $91k
DISCOVER_DINERS 1 0.0% $50 0.0% $50.00 1 0.0% 0/1 $0
TOTAL 24,554 $6,014,914 $244.97 17,060 47.3% $5.58M
Brand x card type - payments taken

Each row sums to 100% across the three type columns, so you can see which brands arrive as debit. AMERICAN_EXPRESS and DISCOVER are effectively credit-only networks here; VISA and MASTERCARD carry both.

BrandDEBITCREDITUNKNOWNTotal
VISA11,915 74.6%4,052 25.4%0 0.0%15,967
MASTERCARD4,102 62.0%2,517 38.0%0 0.0%6,619
DISCOVER620 51.3%588 48.7%0 0.0%1,208
AMERICAN_EXPRESS3 0.4%756 99.6%0 0.0%759
DISCOVER_DINERS0 0.0%1 100.0%0 0.0%1
Prepaid vs funded cards

Square reports prepaid_type straight off the BIN. A prepaid card cannot go overdrawn and cannot be topped up by us, so a recurring plan sitting on one is a different collections risk from one on a funded account.

Prepaid typePayments takenValue taken Avg paymentCustomers Decline rateValue declined
NOT_PREPAID 23,181 94.4% $5,823,712 96.8% $251.23 15,972 45.0% 18,934/42,115 $5.05M
PREPAID 1,368 5.6% $190,364 3.2% $139.16 1,185 69.1% 3,066/4,434 $521k
UNKNOWN 5 0.0% $838 0.0% $167.60 3 0.0% 0/5 $0
TOTAL 24,554 $6,014,914 $244.97 17,060 47.3% $5.58M
Prepaid x card type - payments taken
Prepaid typeDEBITCREDITUNKNOWNTotal
NOT_PREPAID15,297 66.0%7,884 34.0%0 0.0%23,181
PREPAID1,341 98.0%27 2.0%0 0.0%1,368
UNKNOWN2 40.0%3 60.0%0 0.0%5
Prepaid concentration by city - payments taken
CityPREPAIDNOT_PREPAIDUNKNOWNTotal
Texas375 5.8%6,082 94.2%0 0.0%6,457
Florida262 4.9%5,054 95.1%0 0.0%5,316
New York220 5.8%3,571 94.2%1 0.0%3,792
Chicago198 5.9%3,181 94.1%0 0.0%3,379
Nashville206 7.2%2,639 92.8%0 0.0%2,845
Boston107 3.9%2,654 96.0%4 0.1%2,765
Decline rate by card type

The commercially useful cut. Rate = FAILED divided by (FAILED + COMPLETED). The pair beside each rate is failures / attempts, so you can see whether a bad-looking rate stands on real volume.

Card typeAttemptsCompletedFailedDecline rateValue declined
DEBIT34,52516,640 48.2%17,885 51.8%51.8% 17,885/34,525$4,111,409
CREDIT12,0297,914 65.8%4,115 34.2%34.2% 4,115/12,029$1,464,085
UNKNOWN00 -0 -- 0/0$0
TOTAL46,55424,55422,00047.3%$5,575,494
Decline rate - brand x card type
BrandDEBITCREDITUNKNOWNAll cards
VISA51.9% 12,868/24,78335.1% 2,196/6,248- 0/048.5% 15,064/31,031
MASTERCARD51.1% 4,283/8,38536.7% 1,459/3,976- 0/046.5% 5,742/12,361
DISCOVER54.2% 734/1,35425.1% 197/785- 0/043.5% 931/2,139
AMERICAN_EXPRESS0.0% 0/325.8% 263/1,019- 0/025.7% 263/1,022
DISCOVER_DINERS- 0/00.0% 0/1- 0/00.0% 0/1
Decline rate - entry method x card type

An ON_FILE recurring charge and a KEYED point-of-sale charge are different businesses. Reading one blended decline rate across both is how a collections problem hides inside a healthy studio number.

Entry methodDEBITCREDITUNKNOWNAll cards
KEYED17.3% 1,630/9,42316.6% 643/3,870- 0/017.1% 2,273/13,293
ON_FILE68.5% 15,724/22,97146.3% 3,104/6,702- 0/063.5% 18,828/29,673
CONTACTLESS24.7% 400/1,62027.2% 316/1,162- 0/025.7% 716/2,782
EMV25.6% 130/50717.3% 51/294- 0/022.6% 181/801
SWIPED25.0% 1/4100.0% 1/1- 0/040.0% 2/5
Decline rate - city x card type
CityDEBITCREDITUNKNOWNAll cards
Texas54.7% 5,483/10,01937.4% 1,150/3,071- 0/050.7% 6,633/13,090
Florida45.8% 2,985/6,52332.9% 873/2,651- 0/042.1% 3,858/9,174
New York58.2% 3,434/5,90538.0% 811/2,132- 0/052.8% 4,245/8,037
Chicago47.8% 2,054/4,29830.8% 506/1,641- 0/043.1% 2,560/5,939
Nashville51.5% 2,160/4,19633.1% 400/1,209- 0/047.4% 2,560/5,405
Boston49.4% 1,769/3,58428.3% 375/1,325- 0/043.7% 2,144/4,909
Decline rate - month x card type
MonthDEBITCREDITUNKNOWNAll cards
2026-0851.2% 6,069/11,85934.0% 1,400/4,122- 0/046.7% 7,469/15,981
2026-0952.9% 6,011/11,36034.2% 1,365/3,988- 0/048.1% 7,376/15,348
2026-1051.3% 5,805/11,30634.4% 1,350/3,919- 0/047.0% 7,155/15,225
By entry method

ON_FILE is a stored-card charge - the recurring collections book. KEYED is typed in, almost always a studio deposit or sale. CONTACTLESS / EMV / SWIPED are card-present.

Entry methodPayments takenValue taken Avg paymentCustomers Decline rateValue declined
KEYED 11,020 44.9% $1,460,108 24.3% $132.50 10,338 17.1% 2,273/13,293 $656k
ON_FILE 10,845 44.2% $2,147,700 35.7% $198.04 5,628 63.5% 18,828/29,673 $3.79M
CONTACTLESS 2,066 8.4% $1,873,486 31.1% $906.82 1,940 25.7% 716/2,782 $869k
EMV 620 2.5% $533,145 8.9% $859.91 601 22.6% 181/801 $255k
SWIPED 3 0.0% $475 0.0% $158.33 3 40.0% 2/5 $150
TOTAL 24,554 $6,014,914 $244.97 17,060 47.3% $5.58M
Entry method x card type - payments taken
Entry methodDEBITCREDITUNKNOWNTotal
KEYED7,793 70.7%3,227 29.3%0 0.0%11,020
ON_FILE7,247 66.8%3,598 33.2%0 0.0%10,845
CONTACTLESS1,220 59.1%846 40.9%0 0.0%2,066
EMV377 60.8%243 39.2%0 0.0%620
SWIPED3 100.0%0 0.0%0 0.0%3
By city
CityPayments takenValue taken Avg paymentCustomers Decline rateValue declined
Texas 6,457 26.3% $1,564,631 26.0% $242.32 4,428 50.7% 6,633/13,090 $1.59M
Florida 5,316 21.7% $1,456,543 24.2% $273.99 3,804 42.1% 3,858/9,174 $1.14M
New York 3,792 15.4% $879,615 14.6% $231.97 2,659 52.8% 4,245/8,037 $1.04M
Chicago 3,379 13.8% $859,517 14.3% $254.37 2,381 43.1% 2,560/5,939 $731k
Nashville 2,845 11.6% $644,237 10.7% $226.45 1,886 47.4% 2,560/5,405 $569k
Boston 2,765 11.3% $610,371 10.1% $220.75 1,902 43.7% 2,144/4,909 $511k
TOTAL 24,554 $6,014,914 $244.97 17,060 47.3% $5.58M
City x card type - payments taken
CityDEBITCREDITUNKNOWNTotal
Texas4,536 70.2%1,921 29.8%0 0.0%6,457
Florida3,538 66.6%1,778 33.4%0 0.0%5,316
New York2,471 65.2%1,321 34.8%0 0.0%3,792
Chicago2,244 66.4%1,135 33.6%0 0.0%3,379
Nashville2,036 71.6%809 28.4%0 0.0%2,845
Boston1,815 65.6%950 34.4%0 0.0%2,765