Share:

The worst 10% of leads, city by city

2026-08-01 → 2026-10-31 · 113,361 fresh leads · 5,514 bookings · scored out of fold on code × ZIP3 × age
Worst 10%, all cities
11,337
leads · 258 bookings
They book at
2.28%
vs 4.86% overall — 2.1× worse
Best 10% book at
6.69%
2.9× the worst decile
What the decile cost
$165,115
real invoiced spend · $14.56 a lead vs $13.30 across the book
Cost per booking in it
$640
vs $274 across the book
Every city, worst decile against its own average

The decile is cut inside each city, so "worst 10%" always means worst relative to that city's own book — not the eight cities pooled. Index is the decile's booking rate divided by the city's. Lower is worse; 1.00× would mean the decile is no different from the average lead, i.e. nothing separable.

CityLeadsBooks atWorst 10%BookingsBooks atIndexRemovedIts CPLWhat it cost$/bookingCity $/bookingRatio
Boston 11,546 5.66% 1,155 27 2.34% 0.41× 354 30.6% $19.48 $22,504 $833 $269 3.1×
Chicago 16,111 4.64% 1,611 49 3.04% 0.66× 313 19.4% $11.97 $19,276 $393 $292 1.3×
Dallas 14,936 5.25% 1,494 24 1.61% 0.31× 471 31.5% $16.21 $24,212 $1,009 $237 4.3×
Florida 19,267 4.27% 1,927 47 2.44% 0.57× 553 28.7% $15.75 $30,354 $646 $316 2.0×
Houston 14,554 4.51% 1,455 30 2.06% 0.46× 289 19.9% $13.81 $20,094 $670 $312 2.1×
Nashville 9,126 5.72% 913 22 2.41% 0.42× 262 28.7% $15.53 $14,180 $645 $315 2.0×
New York 16,500 5.05% 1,650 42 2.55% 0.50× 395 23.9% $9.58 $15,809 $376 $172 2.2×
Orlando 11,321 4.35% 1,132 17 1.50% 0.34× 318 28.1% $16.51 $18,686 $1,099 $313 3.5×
TOTAL113,3614.86% 11,3372582.28% 0.47×—$14.56$165,115 $640$274 2.3×
What the worst decile is made of — by lead family

Read the In worst decile column as "what share of this family's own leads end up in the bottom 10% of their city". A family running at 10% is contributing its fair share; anything well above that is where the decile actually comes from.

FamilyLeadsBookingsBooks atIn worst decileShare of the decile
Blue Rooms KIDSX31,1561,857 5.96% 0 0.0% 0.0%
Alan FB / IG31,0481,287 4.15% 2,178 7.0% 19.2%
Blue Rooms 1FX27,2951,364 5.00% 3,898 14.3% 34.4%
Lead Pronto19,767913 4.62% 3,946 20.0% 34.8%
Google PMax (GX / KX / PX)4,09593 2.27% 1,315 32.1% 11.6%
… and by age band
Age bandLeadsBookingsBooks atIn worst decileShare of the decile
kids43,3932,181 5.03% 122 0.3% 1.1%
18-2422,0001,428 6.49% 21 0.1% 0.2%
25-3417,4131,000 5.74% 193 1.1% 1.7%
35-4414,538556 3.82% 2,466 17.0% 21.8%
45-549,635223 2.31% 5,071 52.6% 44.7%
55+6,382126 1.97% 3,464 54.3% 30.6%
Boston2.3%
Chicago3.0%
Dallas1.6%
Florida2.4%
Houston2.1%
Nashville2.4%
New York2.5%
Orlando1.5%
Boston — all leads
11,546
654 bookings · 5.66%
Worst 10%
1,155
27 bookings · 2.34%
Index vs the city
0.41×
best 10% books at 7.79%
Removed in the decile
30.6%
vs 17.5% citywide
Off the ZIP target list
0.7%
vs 0.6% citywide
What it cost
$22,504
$19.48 a lead · $833 a booking
The decile, by campaign code and age

The twelve biggest blocks of leads inside Boston's worst 10%. These are the buying decisions — a code and an age bracket is what a media buyer can actually turn down.

Code · ageLeadsBookingsBooks atRemovedCost
BOSLP2 · 55+3938 2.04%135 34.4% $10,509
BOSLP2 · 45-542114 1.90%54 25.6% $5,358
BOS1FX · 45-541737 4.05%43 24.9% $1,524
BOS1FX · 55+1312 1.53%51 38.9% $879
BOSGX · 45-54441 2.27%14 31.8% $504
BOSSNAP · 45-54241 4.17%2 8.3% $484
BOIG23F · 45-54210 0.00%4 19.0% $421
BOIG23F · 55+200 0.00%8 40.0% $401
BOSDX · 45-54180 0.00%6 33.3% $515
BOSGX · 55+170 0.00%5 29.4% $207
BOFB33F · 45-54150 0.00%7 46.7% $255
BOSLP2 · 35-44130 0.00%3 23.1% $345
Where the decile lives — ZIP3
ZIP3LeadsBookingsBooks atOff target list
0211964 2.04%0 0.0%
060751 1.33%0 0.0%
018742 2.70%0 0.0%
028700 0.00%0 0.0%
020570 0.00%0 0.0%
029533 5.66%0 0.0%
015490 0.00%0 0.0%
027440 0.00%0 0.0%
019383 7.89%0 0.0%
025350 0.00%0 0.0%
Age mix of the decile
Age bandLeadsBookingsBooks atShare of the decile
55+58210 1.72%50.4%
45-5453616 2.99%46.4%
35-44371 2.70%3.2%
Boston's kill list — every code × age segment of 80+ leads booking under 1.5%

Whole-window figures, not decile-only, so a segment here is bad everywhere — not bad because the score put it there.

Code · ageLeadsBookingsBooks atCost
BOS3AB · kids3960 0.00%$6,738
Chicago — all leads
16,111
748 bookings · 4.64%
Worst 10%
1,611
49 bookings · 3.04%
Index vs the city
0.66×
best 10% books at 7.14%
Removed in the decile
19.4%
vs 17.3% citywide
Off the ZIP target list
0.1%
vs 0.6% citywide
What it cost
$19,276
$11.97 a lead · $393 a booking
The decile, by campaign code and age

The twelve biggest blocks of leads inside Chicago's worst 10%. These are the buying decisions — a code and an age bracket is what a media buyer can actually turn down.

Code · ageLeadsBookingsBooks atRemovedCost
CHI1FX · 45-5467319 2.82%121 18.0% $6,809
CHI1FX · 55+1764 2.27%45 25.6% $1,781
CHI1FX · 35-441709 5.29%17 10.0% $1,720
CHIGX · 45-54920 0.00%26 28.3% $1,158
CHIFB31M · 25-34925 5.43%17 18.5% $1,598
CHIGX · 25-34613 4.92%14 23.0% $765
CHIFB33F · 45-54601 1.67%11 18.3% $1,042
CHIFB32F · 35-44503 6.00%6 12.0% $869
CHIFB32M · 35-44373 8.11%6 16.2% $643
CHIGX · kids281 3.57%8 28.6% $354
CHIFB33F · 55+260 0.00%6 23.1% $452
CHISNAP · 45-54241 4.17%5 20.8% $213
Where the decile lives — ZIP3
ZIP3LeadsBookingsBooks atOff target list
60677025 3.25%0 0.0%
6011463 2.05%0 0.0%
600771 1.30%0 0.0%
604703 4.29%0 0.0%
532533 5.66%0 0.0%
611480 0.00%0 0.0%
481321 3.13%0 0.0%
464280 0.00%0 0.0%
608251 4.00%0 0.0%
462241 4.17%0 0.0%
Age mix of the decile
Age bandLeadsBookingsBooks atShare of the decile
45-5489821 2.34%55.7%
35-4428115 5.34%17.4%
55+2384 1.68%14.8%
25-341548 5.19%9.6%
kids361 2.78%2.2%
18-2440 0.00%0.2%
Chicago's kill list — every code × age segment of 80+ leads booking under 1.5%

Whole-window figures, not decile-only, so a segment here is bad everywhere — not bad because the score put it there.

Code · ageLeadsBookingsBooks atCost
CHIGX · 45-54920 0.00%$1,158
CHIGX · 35-441101 0.91%$1,382
CHI3AB · kids7438 1.08%$10,533
CHIKDX · kids911 1.10%$4,665
Dallas — all leads
14,936
784 bookings · 5.25%
Worst 10%
1,494
24 bookings · 1.61%
Index vs the city
0.31×
best 10% books at 7.36%
Removed in the decile
31.5%
vs 16.9% citywide
Off the ZIP target list
1.9%
vs 1.8% citywide
What it cost
$24,212
$16.21 a lead · $1,009 a booking
The decile, by campaign code and age

The twelve biggest blocks of leads inside Dallas's worst 10%. These are the buying decisions — a code and an age bracket is what a media buyer can actually turn down.

Code · ageLeadsBookingsBooks atRemovedCost
DALP2 · 55+44510 2.25%167 37.5% $8,572
DALP2 · 45-542706 2.22%68 25.2% $5,238
DAL1FX · 45-542091 0.48%51 24.4% $1,430
DALGX · 45-541521 0.66%45 29.6% $3,445
DAL1FX · 55+821 1.22%42 51.2% $471
DALP2 · 35-44732 2.74%18 24.7% $1,457
DALFB33F · 45-54470 0.00%10 21.3% $590
DAL3CX3F · 45-54430 0.00%9 20.9% $468
DALGX · 55+320 0.00%10 31.3% $690
DAL3CX3F · 55+290 0.00%17 58.6% $316
DALGX · 35-44250 0.00%4 16.0% $457
DALFB33M · 45-54211 4.76%7 33.3% $264
Where the decile lives — ZIP3
ZIP3LeadsBookingsBooks atOff target list
7522471 0.40%0 0.0%
7612352 0.85%0 0.0%
7501963 1.53%0 0.0%
7601065 4.72%0 0.0%
751803 3.75%0 0.0%
731663 4.55%0 0.0%
756651 1.54%0 0.0%
786601 1.67%0 0.0%
762441 2.27%0 0.0%
787431 2.33%0 0.0%
Age mix of the decile
Age bandLeadsBookingsBooks atShare of the decile
45-5476110 1.31%50.9%
55+62212 1.93%41.6%
35-441092 1.83%7.3%
kids20 0.00%0.1%
Dallas's kill list — every code × age segment of 80+ leads booking under 1.5%

Whole-window figures, not decile-only, so a segment here is bad everywhere — not bad because the score put it there.

Code · ageLeadsBookingsBooks atCost
DALGX · 45-541611 0.62%$3,664
DAL3AB · kids6807 1.03%$9,043
Florida — all leads
19,267
822 bookings · 4.27%
Worst 10%
1,927
47 bookings · 2.44%
Index vs the city
0.57×
best 10% books at 5.81%
Removed in the decile
28.7%
vs 15.2% citywide
Off the ZIP target list
0.7%
vs 0.9% citywide
What it cost
$30,354
$15.75 a lead · $646 a booking
The decile, by campaign code and age

The twelve biggest blocks of leads inside Florida's worst 10%. These are the buying decisions — a code and an age bracket is what a media buyer can actually turn down.

Code · ageLeadsBookingsBooks atRemovedCost
FLP2 · 55+40213 3.23%133 33.1% $8,722
FL1FX · 45-5430110 3.32%72 23.9% $3,222
FLP2 · 45-542114 1.90%60 28.4% $4,585
FL1FX · 55+1382 1.45%50 36.2% $1,352
FLP2 · 35-441324 3.03%38 28.8% $2,873
FL1FX · 35-441205 4.17%21 17.5% $802
FLFB32F · 35-441030 0.00%21 20.4% $1,484
FLGX · 35-44832 2.41%20 24.1% $965
FLGX · 45-54810 0.00%23 28.4% $947
FLFB32F · 45-54510 0.00%14 27.5% $735
FLFB31M · 35-44362 5.56%7 19.4% $519
FLGX · kids330 0.00%14 42.4% $390
Where the decile lives — ZIP3
ZIP3LeadsBookingsBooks atOff target list
33193216 1.72%0 0.0%
3302716 2.21%0 0.0%
33419711 5.58%0 0.0%
3421424 2.82%0 0.0%
333942 2.13%0 0.0%
341902 2.22%0 0.0%
339682 2.94%0 0.0%
349221 4.55%0 0.0%
337190 0.00%0 0.0%
335120 0.00%0 0.0%
Age mix of the decile
Age bandLeadsBookingsBooks atShare of the decile
45-5474415 2.02%38.6%
55+60017 2.83%31.1%
35-4449314 2.84%25.6%
kids560 0.00%2.9%
25-34221 4.55%1.1%
18-24120 0.00%0.6%
Florida's kill list — every code × age segment of 80+ leads booking under 1.5%

Whole-window figures, not decile-only, so a segment here is bad everywhere — not bad because the score put it there.

Code · ageLeadsBookingsBooks atCost
FLFB32F · 35-441220 0.00%$1,758
FLGX · 45-54810 0.00%$947
FL4IG32F · 35-44961 1.04%$1,441
FL3AB · kids1,58917 1.07%$21,935
FLKX · kids891 1.12%$282
Houston — all leads
14,554
657 bookings · 4.51%
Worst 10%
1,455
30 bookings · 2.06%
Index vs the city
0.46×
best 10% books at 6.25%
Removed in the decile
19.9%
vs 16.6% citywide
Off the ZIP target list
1.0%
vs 1.5% citywide
What it cost
$20,094
$13.81 a lead · $670 a booking
The decile, by campaign code and age

The twelve biggest blocks of leads inside Houston's worst 10%. These are the buying decisions — a code and an age bracket is what a media buyer can actually turn down.

Code · ageLeadsBookingsBooks atRemovedCost
HOUFB32M · 35-443396 1.77%47 13.9% $4,302
HOU1FX · 45-541997 3.52%40 20.1% $1,596
HOULP2 · 45-541663 1.81%35 21.1% $3,981
HOUGX · 45-541592 1.26%47 29.6% $1,552
HOUGX · 35-441142 1.75%22 19.3% $1,112
HOUFB32F · 35-441053 2.86%10 9.5% $1,332
HOULP2 · 35-44780 0.00%17 21.8% $1,870
HOUFB33F · 45-54542 3.70%13 24.1% $685
HOUGX · 55+401 2.50%22 55.0% $387
HOUFB33M · 45-54381 2.63%4 10.5% $482
HOU1FX · 35-44240 0.00%4 16.7% $161
HOUDX · 45-54211 4.76%3 14.3% $498
Where the decile lives — ZIP3
ZIP3LeadsBookingsBooks atOff target list
77056513 2.30%0 0.0%
7751543 1.95%0 0.0%
7861521 0.66%0 0.0%
7821392 1.44%0 0.0%
7731164 3.45%0 0.0%
787791 1.27%0 0.0%
774332 6.06%0 0.0%
776280 0.00%0 0.0%
781191 5.26%0 0.0%
780180 0.00%0 0.0%
Age mix of the decile
Age bandLeadsBookingsBooks atShare of the decile
45-5467816 2.36%46.6%
35-4467411 1.63%46.3%
55+812 2.47%5.6%
kids171 5.88%1.2%
25-3440 0.00%0.3%
18-2410 0.00%0.1%
Houston's kill list — every code × age segment of 80+ leads booking under 1.5%

Whole-window figures, not decile-only, so a segment here is bad everywhere — not bad because the score put it there.

Code · ageLeadsBookingsBooks atCost
HOULP2 · 45-543474 1.15%$8,321
HOUGX · 45-541592 1.26%$1,552
HOUGX · 35-441342 1.49%$1,307
Nashville — all leads
9,126
522 bookings · 5.72%
Worst 10%
913
22 bookings · 2.41%
Index vs the city
0.42×
best 10% books at 6.68%
Removed in the decile
28.7%
vs 17.1% citywide
Off the ZIP target list
3.8%
vs 1.9% citywide
What it cost
$14,180
$15.53 a lead · $645 a booking
The decile, by campaign code and age

The twelve biggest blocks of leads inside Nashville's worst 10%. These are the buying decisions — a code and an age bracket is what a media buyer can actually turn down.

Code · ageLeadsBookingsBooks atRemovedCost
NA1FX · 45-542589 3.49%61 23.6% $2,179
NALP2 · 45-541011 0.99%32 31.7% $2,660
NA1FX · 55+923 3.26%27 29.3% $783
NALP2 · 55+841 1.19%33 39.3% $2,234
NASGX · 45-54660 0.00%28 42.4% $843
NA1FX · 35-44411 2.44%9 22.0% $402
NAFB33F · 45-54351 2.86%5 14.3% $743
NAFB32F · 35-44352 5.71%6 17.1% $743
NASGX · 35-44340 0.00%7 20.6% $418
NAFB33M · 45-54331 3.03%10 30.3% $701
NADX · 45-54160 0.00%8 50.0% $319
NASGX · 55+150 0.00%9 60.0% $187
Where the decile lives — ZIP3
ZIP3LeadsBookingsBooks atOff target list
372941 1.06%0 0.0%
371844 4.76%0 0.0%
381741 1.35%0 0.0%
370623 4.84%0 0.0%
384550 0.00%0 0.0%
385552 3.64%0 0.0%
378491 2.04%0 0.0%
373403 7.50%0 0.0%
402331 3.03%0 0.0%
383320 0.00%0 0.0%
Age mix of the decile
Age bandLeadsBookingsBooks atShare of the decile
45-5454213 2.40%59.4%
55+2064 1.94%22.6%
35-441475 3.40%16.1%
25-3490 0.00%1.0%
kids60 0.00%0.7%
18-2430 0.00%0.3%
Nashville's kill list — every code × age segment of 80+ leads booking under 1.5%

Whole-window figures, not decile-only, so a segment here is bad everywhere — not bad because the score put it there.

Code · ageLeadsBookingsBooks atCost
NASGX · 45-54890 0.00%$1,141
NALP2 · 45-541772 1.13%$4,236
NALP2 · 55+2333 1.29%$5,602
NA3AB · kids4957 1.41%$9,232
New York — all leads
16,500
834 bookings · 5.05%
Worst 10%
1,650
42 bookings · 2.55%
Index vs the city
0.50×
best 10% books at 6.73%
Removed in the decile
23.9%
vs 13.3% citywide
Off the ZIP target list
0.4%
vs 0.5% citywide
What it cost
$15,809
$9.58 a lead · $376 a booking
The decile, by campaign code and age

The twelve biggest blocks of leads inside New York's worst 10%. These are the buying decisions — a code and an age bracket is what a media buyer can actually turn down.

Code · ageLeadsBookingsBooks atRemovedCost
NY1FX · 35-4439416 4.06%54 13.7% $2,656
NY1FX · 55+2762 0.72%83 30.1% $1,860
NY1FX · 45-5427512 4.36%57 20.7% $1,854
NYLP2 · 55+1800 0.00%53 29.4% $2,551
NYLP2 · 35-441387 5.07%45 32.6% $1,961
NYLP2 · 45-541250 0.00%44 35.2% $1,779
NYSNAP · 35-44854 4.71%18 21.2% $1,167
NYGX · 35-44200 0.00%5 25.0% $141
NYGX · 45-54170 0.00%6 35.3% $120
NYIG22F · 35-44160 0.00%5 31.3% $303
NYFB32M · 35-44150 0.00%1 6.7% $137
NYSNAP · 45-54130 0.00%2 15.4% $178
Where the decile lives — ZIP3
ZIP3LeadsBookingsBooks atOff target list
1121553 1.94%0 0.0%
1041465 3.42%0 0.0%
0701355 3.70%0 0.0%
100823 3.66%0 0.0%
191811 1.23%0 0.0%
113701 1.43%0 0.0%
071591 1.69%0 0.0%
088592 3.39%0 0.0%
080532 3.77%0 0.0%
117472 4.26%0 0.0%
Age mix of the decile
Age bandLeadsBookingsBooks atShare of the decile
35-4470228 3.99%42.5%
55+4752 0.42%28.8%
45-5446412 2.59%28.1%
25-3440 0.00%0.2%
kids40 0.00%0.2%
18-2410 0.00%0.1%
New York's kill list — every code × age segment of 80+ leads booking under 1.5%

Whole-window figures, not decile-only, so a segment here is bad everywhere — not bad because the score put it there.

Code · ageLeadsBookingsBooks atCost
NYLP2 · 55+1800 0.00%$2,551
NYLP2 · 45-541370 0.00%$1,944
NY3AB · kids8396 0.72%$7,670
NY1FX · 55+3194 1.25%$2,150
Orlando — all leads
11,321
493 bookings · 4.35%
Worst 10%
1,132
17 bookings · 1.50%
Index vs the city
0.34×
best 10% books at 6.10%
Removed in the decile
28.1%
vs 21.9% citywide
Off the ZIP target list
16.6%
vs 4.3% citywide
What it cost
$18,686
$16.51 a lead · $1,099 a booking
The decile, by campaign code and age

The twelve biggest blocks of leads inside Orlando's worst 10%. These are the buying decisions — a code and an age bracket is what a media buyer can actually turn down.

Code · ageLeadsBookingsBooks atRemovedCost
ORLP2 · 55+55210 1.81%174 31.5% $10,267
ORLP2 · 45-542915 1.72%51 17.5% $5,413
ORL1FX · 55+831 1.20%31 37.3% $377
ORLGX · 45-54520 0.00%18 34.6% $551
ORL1FX · 45-54490 0.00%12 24.5% $247
ORLFB32F · 45-54391 2.56%14 35.9% $762
ORLP2 · 35-44170 0.00%3 17.6% $316
ORLGX · 55+160 0.00%4 25.0% $187
ORLDX · 45-54100 0.00%2 20.0% $187
ORLFB32F · 55+60 0.00%3 50.0% $117
ORL4IG33F · 45-5460 0.00%2 33.3% $111
ORLGX · 35-4450 0.00%2 40.0% $52
Where the decile lives — ZIP3
ZIP3LeadsBookingsBooks atOff target list
3381721 0.58%0 0.0%
3461703 1.76%0 0.0%
3441592 1.26%0 0.0%
3251170 0.00%117 100.0%
347733 4.11%0 0.0%
323671 1.49%67 100.0%
336581 1.72%0 0.0%
335452 4.44%0 0.0%
342421 2.38%0 0.0%
349391 2.56%0 0.0%
Age mix of the decile
Age bandLeadsBookingsBooks atShare of the decile
55+66011 1.67%58.3%
45-544486 1.34%39.6%
35-44230 0.00%2.0%
kids10 0.00%0.1%
Orlando's kill list — every code × age segment of 80+ leads booking under 1.5%

Whole-window figures, not decile-only, so a segment here is bad everywhere — not bad because the score put it there.

Code · ageLeadsBookingsBooks atCost
ORLFB32F · 35-441100 0.00%$2,148
ORLGX · 35-44891 1.12%$1,021
ORLGX · 45-54861 1.16%$983
Cut the worst 10% — spend saved
$165,115
over the quarter, real invoiced cost
Bookings given up
258
86 a month
Cash up front given up
$113,418
105 sales
Net
+$51,697
spend saved less cash lost
Booking rate
4.86% → 5.15%
cost per booking $274 → $256
Read this before the tables

You cannot buy "not the bottom decile". The decile is a score this page computes; no supplier sells against it. So the first cut below is the ceiling — what a perfect filter would do — and the other two are things you could actually do on Monday. The gap between them is the real answer to "what happens if we take those leads out".

Cutting a campaign is also not the same as cutting its bad leads. Turn off PMax and you lose its 93 bookings too, not just its waste. That is why the PMax row saves the most money and gives up the most.

The three cuts, whole book
ScenarioLeadsAd spendCPLBookingsBooks at$/bookingSalesCash up frontCash − spendvs now
As it is now 113,361 $1,508,122 $13.30 5,514 4.86% $274 2,443 $2,388,444 $880,322 baseline
Minus the worst 10% 102,024 $1,343,007 $13.16 5,256 5.15% $256 2,338 $2,275,026 $932,019 +$51,697
Minus the kill list 111,044 $1,477,021 $13.30 5,506 4.96% $268 2,441 $2,386,694 $909,673 +$29,351
Minus all Google PMax 109,266 $1,459,403 $13.36 5,421 4.96% $269 2,403 $2,357,297 $897,895 +$17,573
What each cut changes

Green is better off, red is worse off. Net is spend saved less cash up front given up — the only column that answers whether the cut is worth making.

ScenarioCan you actually buy it?LeadsSpendBookingsSalesCashNet
Minus the worst 10% NOT BUYABLE — the ceiling, not a plan −11,337 +$165,115 saved −258 −105 −$113,418 +$51,697
Minus the kill list BUYABLE — it is an age-targeting change −2,317 +$31,101 saved −8 −2 −$1,750 +$29,351
Minus all Google PMax BUYABLE — one switch −4,095 +$48,719 saved −93 −40 −$31,147 +$17,573
City by city — now vs minus its own worst 10%
CityLeadsBooks atGainCPLSpend savedBookings lost$/bookingBetter by
Boston 11,546 → 10,391 5.66% → 6.03% +0.37pp $15.26 → $14.79 $22,504 27 $269 → $245 −9%
Chicago 16,111 → 14,500 4.64% → 4.82% +0.18pp $13.58 → $13.76 $19,276 49 $292 → $285 −2%
Dallas 14,936 → 13,442 5.25% → 5.65% +0.40pp $12.43 → $12.01 $24,212 24 $237 → $212 −10%
Florida 19,267 → 17,340 4.27% → 4.47% +0.20pp $13.48 → $13.23 $30,354 47 $316 → $296 −6%
Houston 14,554 → 13,099 4.51% → 4.79% +0.27pp $14.09 → $14.13 $20,094 30 $312 → $295 −5%
Nashville 9,126 → 8,213 5.72% → 6.09% +0.37pp $18.04 → $18.32 $14,180 22 $315 → $301 −5%
New York 16,500 → 14,850 5.05% → 5.33% +0.28pp $8.70 → $8.61 $15,809 42 $172 → $161 −6%
Orlando 11,321 → 10,189 4.35% → 4.67% +0.32pp $13.64 → $13.32 $18,686 17 $313 → $285 −9%
TOTAL 113,361 → 102,024 4.86% → 5.15% +0.29pp $13.30 → $13.16 $165,115 258 $274 → $256 −7%
The hole to fill
3,779
leads a month — 7.2% of everything the bookers see
Recycled people available
324,644
never booked, quiet 90+ days
Recycled books at
2.82%
vs 2.28% for the leads you would drop
Best use of the saving
Blue Rooms KIDSX
$11.35 a lead, books at 5.96%
First, how big is the hole?

The bookers see 156,870 leads a quarter — 113,361 fresh and 43,509 recycled, about 52,290 a month. That total, not the fresh count, is the number a cut has to be measured against.

CutLeads a quartera monthof what bookers seeBookings lostSpend saved
Cut the worst 10% 11,337 3,779 7.2% 258 $165,115
Cut the kill list 2,317 772 1.5% 8 $31,101
Cut all Google PMax 4,095 1,365 2.6% 93 $48,719
Option 1 — fill it with recycled. Which family you pull decides everything.

Recycled costs no new ad money, so anything it books is free. Blended as it is sent today it books at 2.82% — already 1.2× the 2.28% of the leads you would be dropping. But the families are nothing like each other, and the supply of the good ones is the real limit.

Recycled familySent this quarterBooks at11,337 of it would bookvs the 258 lostIs there enough?
CMN 5,622 5.73% 649 +391 2.0× a quarter's supply
FL01 organic 918 5.56% 630 +372 12.3× a quarter's supply
…R variant 8,146 3.14% 356 +98 1.4× a quarter's supply
5AB 3,940 2.59% 293 +35 2.9× a quarter's supply
6AB 11,908 2.29% 260 +2 enough
N1N 12,933 1.72% 195 −63 enough
Blended, exactly as it is sent today43,509 2.82%320 +62—

Read the last column before the fourth. CMN is the best recycled lead we have and there is nowhere near enough of it — filling the whole hole from CMN would need more than a quarter's entire supply. A realistic backfill is CMN and 5AB first, then 6AB, and N1N last.

Is there enough to pull from? Yes — by a very long way

People, not lead rows — 713,553 rows over 13 months are 475,481 people, 1.5 rows each. A person is in the pool if they have never booked and we have not touched them for that long.

PoolPeopleAt the cut rate, that isBiggest cities
Not touched for 30+ days408,770 108 months New York 81,911 · Florida 62,276 · Houston 58,563 · Dallas 57,065
Not touched for 60+ days364,530 96 months New York 75,313 · Florida 54,200 · Houston 53,036 · Dallas 51,473
Not touched for 90+ days324,644 86 months New York 69,931 · Houston 47,560 · Florida 46,983 · Dallas 46,602
Not touched for 180+ days220,904 58 months New York 55,027 · Houston 33,150 · Dallas 32,186 · Florida 29,605

So supply is not the constraint and never was. The constraint is response: these are people who have already not booked. That is why the family mix above matters more than the pool size, and why a fourth send to the same person books at almost nothing.

Option 2 — spend the saving on the leads that actually work

$165,115 freed by cutting the worst 10%, at each family's own real cost per lead. This is the option the numbers prefer, and it is not close.

FamilyLeads this quarterBooks atReal CPL$/booking$165,115 buyswhich booksvs the 258 lost
Blue Rooms KIDSX 31,156 5.96% $11.35 $190 14,552 867 +609
Blue Rooms SNAP 3,891 5.81% $16.26 $280 10,157 590 +332
Blue Rooms 1FX 27,295 5.00% $8.48 $170 19,463 973 +715
Lead Pronto 19,767 4.62% $20.37 $441 8,107 374 +116
Alan FB / IG / AdWords 25,692 4.08% $14.69 $360 11,242 459 +201
Google PMax (GX / KX / PX / DX) 5,560 1.89% $14.36 $761 11,495 217 −41

The honest caveat, and it is a big one. Every row assumes the CPL holds as you scale, and it will not — Blue Rooms' cost per booking tripled between April and July as volume rose, and Hash has bid-capped the ad sets 20% below where they were coming in. Treat these as the size of the prize, not a forecast. The safe version is to move money in steps and watch the CPL after each one.

Option 3 — do both, which is what the numbers actually point at

The two options solve different problems. Recycled fixes the bookers' volume for free. The reinvestment fixes the bookings. Nothing stops you doing both: cut the bad fresh spend, hold the bookers' desk volume with CMN and 5AB, and move the money into Blue Rooms KIDSX and Blue Rooms SNAP.

And if you only do one thing: Google PMax costs $761 a booking while Blue Rooms KIDSX costs $190. They cost almost exactly the same per lead. That is the whole argument on one line.

Every code × age segment of 80+ leads that booked under 1%

This table does not use the score at all. It is the plain whole-window record: a code, an age bracket, enough volume to mean something, and a booking rate under one percent. If you want a list to act on tomorrow without accepting a word of the modelling, this is it.

CityCode · ageLeadsBookingsBooks atRemovedCost
New YorkNY3AB · kids839 6 0.72% 102 12.2% $7,670
BostonBOS3AB · kids396 0 0.00% 53 13.4% $6,738
New YorkNYLP2 · 55+180 0 0.00% 53 29.4% $2,551
DallasDALGX · 45-54161 1 0.62% 49 30.4% $3,664
New YorkNYLP2 · 45-54137 0 0.00% 48 35.0% $1,944
FloridaFLFB32F · 35-44122 0 0.00% 22 18.0% $1,758
ChicagoCHIGX · 35-44110 1 0.91% 26 23.6% $1,382
OrlandoORLFB32F · 35-44110 0 0.00% 24 21.8% $2,148
ChicagoCHIGX · 45-5492 0 0.00% 26 28.3% $1,158
NashvilleNASGX · 45-5489 0 0.00% 34 38.2% $1,141
FloridaFLGX · 45-5481 0 0.00% 23 28.4% $947
TOTAL11 segments2,31780.35%—$31,101
No flat cost per lead is used anywhere on this page

Neil, 16 Sep 2026: "we now have the actual lead cost for each of those. please do not use a standard lead cost across the board, as they are all very different." They are: Alan's DALFB3 runs $7.52 a lead and his HOU3CX runs $27.68 in the same quarter. Every lead here is priced by its own campaign code in its own month, from the supplier that invoiced it.

Three sources, none of them a blend. Alan — his own client-reporting portal at leadcodes.vercel.app, per code per day, the system he invoices from. Blue Rooms — invoiced spend per campaign per month from the USA Models portal's JSON API. Lead Pronto — Lauren Renshaw's own monthly report, in GBP, converted at 1.3198.

BasisLeadsShareWhat it means
invoice22,86520.2%The supplier billed this exact code this month — their spend over their own lead count.
spend/our-leads44,73739.5%The supplier billed spend but reports no lead count (Blue Rooms), so it is their invoiced spend over the FRESH leads we received on that code that month.
code-average37,25532.9%No cost for this code in this month, but it is costed in another month of the window — its own average is used.
city-average8,5047.5%This code is costed nowhere. The city's blended cost per fresh lead is used. This is the only inferred number on the page.

How fresh is this? lead_costs.json was built 2026-11-16. Two of its three sources are BANKED BROWSER PULLS, not live feeds — Alan's portal and the USA Models portal are both session-gated, so they are pulled in Neil's Chrome and written to data/. A nightly rebuild of this page re-reads those files; it does not re-pull them. Sources in use: data/alan_leadcodes_2026-09-16.txt (session-gated; pulled in Neil's logged-in Chrome) and data/usa_models_spend_2026-09-16.txt.

Cost per fresh lead, by city — this is the spread a flat CPL hides
CityLeadsAd spendCost per leadCPL of its worst 10%Cost per booking
Boston11,546$176,187 $15.26 $19.48 $269
Chicago16,111$218,777 $13.58 $11.97 $292
Dallas14,936$185,586 $12.43 $16.21 $237
Florida19,267$259,730 $13.48 $15.75 $316
Houston14,554$205,123 $14.09 $13.81 $312
Nashville9,126$164,676 $18.04 $15.53 $315
New York16,500$143,614 $8.70 $9.58 $172
Orlando11,321$154,428 $13.64 $16.51 $313
Flagged — 15 cost entries that do not look right

Neil: "anything that looks too far out of the normal range please flag as we found they were wrong a lot." These are the entries the builder refused to take at face value. A CPL under $2 or over $60 is a broken feed, not a cheap or expensive campaign, so those leads fall through to their code's own average instead.

MonthSupplierCodeLeadsSpendWhat is wrong
2025-11Lead ProntoCHILP1M 1$75 CPL outside the credible range
2025-12Lead ProntoDALP2M 2$170 CPL outside the credible range
2026-01Lead ProntoBOSLP2M 17$1,480 CPL outside the credible range
2026-01Lead ProntoBOSLP3M 20$1,243 CPL outside the credible range
2026-01Lead ProntoFLP1F 105$6,404 CPL outside the credible range
2026-01Lead ProntoORLP2 1,179$513 CPL outside the credible range
2026-05Lead ProntoHOULP2 220$2,546 only 2 weekly report(s) exist for this month — this is a CPL for those weeks, not the month
2026-06AlanBOFB3 36$0 leads with NO spend in Alan's portal — uncosted
2026-06AlanNYFB3 102$0 leads with NO spend in Alan's portal — uncosted
2026-06Lead ProntoHOULP2 361$4,955 only 2 weekly report(s) exist for this month — this is a CPL for those weeks, not the month
2026-07AlanBOFB3 8$0 leads with NO spend in Alan's portal — uncosted
2026-07AlanNY3CX 29$0 leads with NO spend in Alan's portal — uncosted
2026-07AlanNYFB3 100$0 leads with NO spend in Alan's portal — uncosted
2026-07AlanNYIG2 31$0 leads with NO spend in Alan's portal — uncosted
2026-08AlanNYFB3 20$6 CPL $0.3 is below $2 — not credible
Why Alan is costed per CHANNEL and never per code

At full code level (BOIG23F, DAL3CX2M …) his portal misaligns leads and spend across the tier and gender splits inside one channel: 8 code-months with leads and no spend, 16 with spend and no leads, and 37 at under $2 or over $60 a lead. Rolling up to the channel the money is actually bought on (BOIG2, DAL3CX) clears almost all of it. The remainder is in the flagged table above.

The worst of them: 2026-06 DAL3CX2F $91.42/lead (24 leads) · 2026-06 DAL3CX2M $107.82/lead (11 leads) · 2026-06 DAL3CX3F $130.38/lead (16 leads) · 2026-06 DAL3CX3M $81.46/lead (13 leads) · 2026-06 DALFB31F $1.98/lead (80 leads) · 2026-06 DALFB31M $0.63/lead (102 leads).

One genuine hole survives the roll-up. New York's NYFB3 carries 222 leads for $6 across the quarter. That is not a cheap channel, it is a channel Alan's portal is not costing at all — worth putting to him directly.

Is the bad tail growing or shrinking?

The decile is cut once across the whole window, so each month's share of it moves. A month above 10% contributed more than its share of the bad leads; below 10% and it contributed less. This is the column that says whether the problem is being fixed.

MonthLeadsBookingsBooks atOf the worst decileThat decile books at
2026-08 41,3542,1265.14% 3,918 9.5% 1.89%
2026-09 33,0561,6565.01% 3,705 11.2% 2.29%
2026-10 38,9511,7324.45% 3,714 9.5% 2.67%
What "worst" means here

Each lead is scored on three things at once — its campaign code, its 3-digit ZIP and its age band — and the score is that lead's expected booking rate. Every city's leads are then sorted worst-first and cut at 10%. Nothing else is in the score: not the supplier, not the day, not the booker.

The three combine multiplicatively against the city's own mean, each shrunk toward it with a prior worth 250 leads. Shrinkage is not decoration: ranking raw rates ascending fills the worst list with twenty-lead cells at 0.0% and pushes the genuinely large problems off the page. With a prior this strong a segment has to carry real volume to move, so the decile fills with leads burned.

Every rate on this page is out-of-sample

The model is fitted 3 times, each time leaving one calendar month out, and every lead is scored by the fit that never saw its own month (2026-08, 2026-09, 2026-10). This matters more than it sounds: in-sample, a bottom decile is guaranteed to look terrible — that is arithmetic, not a finding. Out of fold it is a prediction that either holds or does not.

It holds. The bottom decile books at 2.28% against 4.86% overall, on leads the model had never seen.

The population

113,361 leads, 2026-08-01 to 2026-10-31 — every fresh lead on a known city code. Recycled codes are out (43,509 of them: they were never bought). Unknown-city codes are out (2,976) — including every #AT Atlanta lead, which no report can score until the Atlanta ZIP sheet exists.

Dupes, removed and rejected leads all stay in. That is deliberate and it is not the /lead-funnel "usable" figure: the question is what the money bought, and a lead the team had to throw away is exactly what makes a decile bad.

Bookings join on name + marketing code, never name + date — Date Distributed is not Date Lead In, and keying on the date matches under 8% of bookings and produces a plausible-looking 0.1% rate. 6,870 of 7,854 booking rows matched (87.5%); the remainder are mostly bookings against recycled and out-of-window leads. Booking, removal and rejection feeds are read past the window end so a late outcome still lands on the lead that earned it.

Four things to hold on to before quoting any of this

1. The money is real, but 7.5% of it is inferred. No flat CPL is used anywhere on this page — every lead is priced by its own code in its own month, from the supplier that invoiced it. 59.6% of leads come straight off an invoice. The rest fall back to the code's own average in another month (37,255 leads) or, where a code is costed nowhere, to that city's blended cost per fresh lead (8,504 leads). See the Cost basis tab.

2. Booking rate understates how bad the decile is. It stops at the booking. The same things that depress booking — distance and age — also depress the show rate (/distance-age: 64.6% at ≤25 mi down to 51.4% at 100–200 mi; 68.0% for under-18s down to 51.1% at 55+). A decile that books at a third of the average shows up at less than a third.

3. The decile still contains bookings. 258 of them. Cutting it is not free — that is the number to weigh the saving against.

4. The score cannot see interactions. The three dimensions multiply, so a code that is bad overall drags down every age band inside it even where one band is genuinely good. New York's GX codes do exactly that. Where the kill list and the decile disagree, the kill list is the plainer record.